Tag Archives: baltic economies

Key milestone is approaching for Estonia’s 2011 euro bid

Estonia’s long and arduous endeavor to become the 17th country to adopt the euro as its official currency will reach a key milestone next week. The European Commission will issue its official report approving or rejecting Estonia’s application on 12 May.

So what will the report conclude? In spite of the financial market turbulence wrought by the unstable situation in Greece, most analysts expect the EC to give Estonia a thumbs-up. A Reuters backgrounder out today concludes that the EC is “expected to grudgingly let in Estonia”. And Estonia’s bid continues to be supported by its closest neighbors. In an interview published yesterday, Finnish finance minister Jyrki Katainen was upbeat:

“Estonia has coped with a decline in economic activity of 10% and obviously still fulfills the criteria” for adoption of the common currency, he said. “In my opinion, nothing argues against the planned acceptance into monetary union next year.”

Latvian Prime Minister Valdis Dombrovskis was even more adamant, asserting in a speech last week in Munich: “We would like to highlight the importance of Estonia joining the euro zone at the earliest opportunity, for the economic recovery and stability of the whole Baltic region.”

Doubts have been raised, however, by an economic report released today which shows that Estonian consumer prices increased at an annual rate of 2.9% in April, the highest rate of inflation the country has seen since February 2009. And public comments issued by Olli Rehn, European Commissioner for Economic and Monetary Affairs, have become less favorable than they were just a few months ago.

Assuming a favorable report by the EC, will euro adoption be a good thing or a bad thing for Estonia? I summarized the arguments for and against the adoption of the euro in this earlier post. The Estonian political leadership is still 100% in favor of monetary union, and Estonian popular opinion is still decidedly lukewarm.

Estonian unemployment is still climbing

There were fewer jobs and more job seekers in Estonia in the 4th quarter of 2009. According to the Estonian Labor Force Survey conducted by Statistics Estonia, the country’s unemployment rate increased to 15.5% and the number of unemployed persons rose to 107,000. Both figures are record highs for the period since 1991.

Estonia’s unemployment rate remains the 3rd-highest in Europe, trailing only Latvia (22.8%) and Spain (19.5%). The 4th quarter unemployment rate across the 27-member European Union was 9.6%. Unemployment in the United States at the end of the 4th quarter was 10.0%.

As discussed in this earlier post, the job picture for young people aged 15 to 24 is particularly bad. Moreover, according to the Estonian Labor Force Survey, the number of children suffering from the effects of their parents’ unemployment is also increasing:

[M]ore and more children are in [a] difficult economic situation. The number of children (less than 18 years of age) in … jobless households was 37,000 in the 4th quarter of 2009, which is over two times more than a year ago.

The survey also asked respondents how well they were coping, and the results are sadly unsurprising: fewer than half of all respondents rated their coping as “satisfactory,” with 16% of the population (164,000 people) reporting “great difficulties” in coping.

Let’s hope things begin to turn around soon.

Precisely how miserable is Estonia?

The economic crisis has hit Estonia hard. As this blog has noted, Estonia’s economic output declined at an annualized rate of 15.6% in the third quarter, and the country’s unemployment rate, at 14.6%, is a modern record for Estonia and the third highest in Europe. The only Estonian industry showing any growth at all is fisheries, and Estonian construction workers have fled to Finland in search of employment.

Today’s New York Times cites a new Moody’s report that compares a mainly European group of countries on the basis of a newly contrived misery index. This index adds together a country’s unemployment rate and its government budget deficit, calculated as a percentage of its gross domestic product. The resulting total represents the country’s misery index, which

captures the current conundrum for many countries: their economies need stimulus, but their budgets may not be able to afford it.

Estonia scores a misery index of about 18%, placing it between Portugal (less miserable) and France (more miserable) in the league tables. But Estonia is considerably less miserable than the United States and Britain, and far better off than misery leaders Spain, Latvia, and Lithuania (each close to 30%). View the complete tables here.

None of these countries is in great shape, but the figures suggest that the Estonian government has a bit more flexibility to implement economic stimulus measures than do its Baltic neighbors.

Estonian economy: good if you’re a fisherman

Growth industry

In my post on Estonia’s third quarter gross domestic product (GDP) report last month, I took the glass-half-full approach and ventured that the numbers suggested the Estonian economy had turned the corner. The revised figures, just released by Statistics Estonia, show that the corner was not as sharp as we thought.

The original numbers had the Estonian economy contracting by 15.3% in the quarter ended September 30th; the revision shows that actual GDP contraction was 15.6%. This still represents an improvement over the second quarter, during which economic output fell 16.1%, but one that is less pronounced than the preliminary numbers suggested.

The official GDP revision also included some eye-popping numbers on the performance of individual components of the Estonian economy. The only industry that grew meaningfully in the third quarter was fishing.

The biggest loser was construction, where economic activity fell by a whopping 32%. No wonder so many Estonian construction workers have gone to Helsinki looking for work.

Has the Estonian economy turned the corner?

At the Tallinn Central Market (keskturg)

Economic activity at Keskturg (Tallinn Central Market)

The official estimate of Estonia’s third-quarter gross domestic product (GDP) was released today by Statistics Estonia. The number is grim, but if you squint and tilt your head a bit you might—just possibly—be able to see the glass as half-full.

The total value of all goods and services produced by Estonia in the July-through-September period this year declined by 15.3% compared to what was produced in the comparable period of 2008.

To place this in a regional perspective, Estonia’s GDP collapsed more than did Lithuania’s (down 14.3%), but it wasn’t quite as bad as Latvia’s (down 18.4%).

SEB economist Mikael Johansson (quoted in this Dow Jones wire report) sees in the 3rd quarter data a sign that the Estonian economy has stabilized. His cautious optimism is supported by this Statistics Estonia chart:

estonia 3q gdp

The bars show the ugly quarterly GDP declines, stretching back nearly two years. But optimists will want to focus on the pink line, which shows that the rate of decline in Estonian exports bottomed out in the 1st quarter and that exports have been shrinking more slowly over the past 6 months; and the red line, which suggests a bottoming of industrial decline in the 2nd quarter.

One footnote: Statistics Estonia notes that the -15.3% GDP figure is a preliminary, “flash” estimate; a more accurate 3rd quarter GDP estimate will be released on the 9th of December. Mark your calendar.