Tag Archives: estonian russian relations

Back on the blog

Greetings to all! Estonia on the Map has returned from its mid-winter hibernation. I’m looking forward to resuming EOTM’s observations and ruminations on contemporary Estonia in the days and weeks ahead.

But first, here’s a quick update on Back on the Map. Sales of the book have been brisk, and I appreciate the wonderful comments that readers have posted, both on this blog and on the book’s page on amazon.com. The promised bonus features — the playlist, the 1992 photo album, and the long-awaited “lost” chapter — are nearly ready for release and will be rolled out in February. Watch for details soon.

February is also a weighty month in the Estonian calendar. Even before the country sends 27 talented athletes with high hopes to the Winter Olympics in Vancouver, Estonia is set to observe the 90th anniversary of the signing of the Tartu Peace Treaty on February 2nd. And three weeks later, on February 24th, comes the celebration of Estonian Independence Day. Watch for full coverage of these events and milestones, and lots more too, here on Estonia on the Map.

Percentage of foreign citizens in Estonia’s population is 3rd-highest in Europe

Estonia ranks third in the European Union in its proportion of foreign citizens, according to a study published last week by the EU’s statistical agency Eurostat to mark International Migrants Day. Foreign citizens comprise approximately 17% of Estonia’s population, placing Estonia third behind Luxembourg (43%) and Latvia (18%).

At the bottom of the rankings is Romania, with foreign citizens representing just 0.1% of its population.

Who are Estonia’s foreign citizens? The Eurostat study is silent on this question, with a footnote that detailed data on Estonia is unavailable. But some insight can be gained by looking at the data for neighbor Latvia. According to Eurostat, most (89.5%) of Latvia’s foreign citizens are classified as recognized non-citizens, a category defined as:

… [A] person who is neither a citizen of the reporting country nor of any other country, but who has established links to that country which includes some but not all rights and obligations of full citizenship.

One can reasonably assume that a similar proportion of Estonia’s foreign citizens is made up of recognized non-citizens. And just who are these RNCs? According to 2000 census figures, 25.6% of Estonia’s population is ethnically Russian, with another 2.1% Ukrainian and 1.3% Belarusian.

Would you be surprised to learn that the majority of foreign-citizenship leader Luxembourg’s foreign citizens are Portuguese? The complete study is here.

Remembering Estonia’s tragic history

Coat of arms of the Republic of EstoniaEstonia is often depicted as a place of quirky and tech-savvy coolness and the country has, for the most part, earned its hip reputation. But as fun as it may be to write or blog about the country’s cheap booze, pretty women, ever-expanding wireless hotspots, wife-carrying domination, etc., we shouldn’t forget that Estonia’s experience for much of the 20th century was pretty rotten.

The first modern era of independence (1918 – 1940) is usually remembered as a rose-tinted idyll, but it was darkened by the global economic depression and tragically cut short by the 1939 Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact, which opened the door to Soviet occupation the following year. But then Nazi Germany declared war on the Soviet Union, and before long they had driven the Soviets out of Estonia, replacing the Communist occupation with a fascist occupation that lasted three years. Then the Soviets drove out the Nazis, won the war, and kept Estonia for themselves.

As I write in chapters 6 and 15 of my book, the Estonians caught up in this nightmare faced deportation, execution, or, if they were lucky, some very unpalatable choices. These choices were articulated starkly by Baltic scholar Anu Mai Köll in a recent talk at Stanford University:

[T]he procedure of deporting Estonians was similar in nature to deportations in other Soviet-occupied countries. What differentiated Estonia and the Baltic states was the legacy of the German occupation during the war …. Anyone thought to be a Nazi sympathizer was automatically subject to interrogations and arrests …. The Nazis became “the enemy of my enemy,” to borrow the old proverb. Brutalized by the Soviets, and caught between the voracious appetites of Hitler and Stalin, it would seem that the Estonians viewed Germans as the lesser of two evils.

You can read more about Professor Köll’s presentation here, and read about her research here. And this is a good place to begin a more thorough exploration of Estonian history.

A half step forward for Estonian-Russian relations?

An important theme in my book is the tenuous state of relations between ethnic Estonians and ethnic Russians in Estonia in 1992. With the notable exception of the unfortunate bronze soldier riots in 2007, relations have generally improved, as more and more ethnic Russians have gained the right to vote and have joined the Estonian political process.

Now comes a story out of Kohtla-Järve, a heavily Russian city in northeastern Estonia. It seems that a doctor (an orthopedic surgeon, no less) lost his temper and “threw a 14-year-old boy’s passport into a bin because the boy could not speak Estonian and answered questions in Russian”. Score one step backwards for inter-ethnic relations.

But the story doesn’t end there. The Estonian medical community quickly distanced itself from the doctor’s behavior, and he was fired from the hospital in which he worked. The latter move may have been a bit of an overreaction, but overall I think we can score it as at least one-and-a-half steps forward. So, net gain = 1/2 step.

Baltic Reports has complete coverage of the incident here.